Start here

If you have not chosen an instrument yet, nothing else on this site matters. This section covers the decisions that come before the shopping.

Most people arrive at a first instrument through one of three doors. A school sends home a form asking which instrument a child would like to play in band or orchestra. A child asks for a guitar. Or an adult decides, quietly and slightly self-consciously, that they would like to learn something. The three routes lead to genuinely different answers, and the biggest mistakes happen when advice written for one is applied to another.

The school route has the most constraints and the fewest genuinely free choices. The instrument has to be one the program teaches, the method book has to be the one the class is working from, and in many districts the brand has to be one the school’s repair technician will service. That sounds restrictive; it is actually a gift, because it removes most of the decisions. The one decision it leaves you is rent or buy, and that is a question of arithmetic rather than taste.

The “my child wants a guitar” route has no constraints at all, which is why it goes wrong more often. The two questions that decide everything are size and string type, and both are answered by measuring a child rather than by reading their birthday off a chart. A guitar that is too big does not produce a slow learner; it produces a child who concludes they are bad at guitar. That is a much harder problem to fix than buying the right size in the first place.

The adult beginner has the opposite problem: too much freedom and a nagging sense of being late. There is no instrument you are too old to start. There are instruments that reward an adult’s patience and reading ability faster than others, and there are a few where the physical demands genuinely favor starting young. That is a real difference and it is worth knowing which is which before you commit.

The four questions, in order

Every page in this section answers one of four questions, and they are genuinely sequential. Answering them out of order is how people end up returning things.

1. Which instrument? Driven by the player’s physical size, the household’s tolerance for noise, and what a school program actually offers.
2. What will it really cost? Not the sticker price. The instrument, the book, the stand, the reeds or strings that need replacing, and the lessons if there are lessons.
3. Rent, buy new, or buy used? A genuine three-way decision with a different answer per instrument, and the one place where our commercial interest and your interest point in different directions. We say so on those pages, every time.
4. What size? Only relevant for the string family and for guitars, and completely decisive there.

What we can and cannot help with

We compile published specifications, read manufacturer manuals, work out cost-of-ownership arithmetic, and check sizing conventions against more than one source. We have not played any of the instruments on this site and we do not pretend otherwise — our methodology page sets out exactly what that means, what we do instead, and how to check our work.

What we cannot do is replace the person teaching the student. A director or a private teacher has heard this specific child play, knows the program, and knows which local shop does a good setup. Where their advice and ours differ, theirs wins.